Fa. Flachskampf et al., OVERESTIMATION OF FLOW VELOCITY THROUGH LEAKS IN MECHANICAL VALVE PROSTHESES AND THROUGH SMALL ORIFICES BY CONTINUOUS-WAVE DOPPLER, Journal of the American Society of Echocardiography, 10(9), 1997, pp. 904-914
The reliability of continuous-wave Doppler flow velocity measurements
through small regurgitant lesions, such as in prosthetic leakage, has
not been systematically analyzed. To evaluate the accuracy of continuo
us-wave Doppler in prosthetic valve leakage and small orifices in an i
n vitro, steady-flow model-flow velocities through the leaks of twelve
intact mechanical prostheses and through six circular nozzles (area 0
.5 to 20 mm(2)) were measured at pressure drops between 30 and 105 mm
Hg. These results were compared with those predicted by the modified B
ernoulli equation. Laser Doppler anemometry of flow velocities through
the nozzles was also performed. Despite high correlation, there was s
ubstantial overestimation of Bernoulli predicted velocities by echo Do
ppler in the prosthetic leaks (mean +12.3% +/- 9.4%; range 90.3% to 14
3.4%). In the nozzles less than or equal to 10 mm(2), but not in the l
argest (20 mm(2)) nozzle, there was also overestimation of the Bernoul
li predicted velocities (mean +6.2% +/- 2%). Laser Doppler anemometry
of flow velocities through the nozzles showed slightly lower values th
an predicted by the Bernoulli equation. Thus, continuous-wave echo Dop
pler overestimates flow velocities through small orifices. This appare
ntly is, at least in part, due to transit time effects and should be t
aken into account when using echo Doppler in small (<10 mm(2)) orifice
s, such as in mild to moderate regurgitant lesions and prosthetic valv
e leakage.