This study tests the hypothesis that common stock call options are exe
rcised rationally and in accordance with the commonly used frictionles
s markets boundary conditions. Using two years of historical early exe
rcise data for common stock call options, the results show that contra
ry to the frictionless markets boundary conditions, approximately 20 p
ercent of the early call exercise occurs at times other than ex-divide
nd dates. While most of the non-dividend related early exercise may be
explained by transactions costs, a significant number of contracts ap
pear to be exercised irrationally. These results suggest that failure
to incorporate market frictions in option pricing models is likely to
lead to specification error.