Te. Kleindienst et al., EVALUATION OF THE PERFORMANCE OF DNPH-COATED SILICA-GEL AND C-18 CARTRIDGES IN THE MEASUREMENT OF FORMALDEHYDE IN THE PRESENCE AND ABSENCE OF OZONE, Environmental science & technology, 32(1), 1998, pp. 124-130
Formaldehyde (HCHO) is an important photochemical product generated du
ring the oxidation of volatile organic compounds in the troposphere. A
ccurate HCHO concentrations are essential for developing a quantitativ
e basis for ozone formation and represent a primary monitoring objecti
ve for the Photochemical Assessment and Monitoring Stations (PAMS). In
the PAMS network, measurements of HCHO are conducted by a derivatizat
ion method using cartridges coated with 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine (DN
PH). In this study, a manifold system has been designed to evaluate th
e performance, accuracy, and importance of interferences of DNPH-coate
d silica gel and C-18 cartridges using gasphase calibration standards.
Compared to the independent gas-phase calibration values, HCHO values
from silica gel cartridges were typically 5% lower than the reference
values over the range of 2-25 ppbv; C-18 cartridge values were system
atically lower by 20%. These results were found to be independent of t
he level of humidity in the system. The HCHO measurements of the two c
artridge systems were highly correlated and yielded the regression equ
ation, [HCHO]C-18 = 0.84[HCHO]S-18 Gel. Measurement of HCHO in the pre
sence of ozone by silica gel cartridges led to a negative interference
, which has been widely reported. The magnitude of the interference wa
s greater than 50% under conditions representative of urban environmen
ts (HCHO = 5 ppb; O-3 = 120 ppb). The interference was routinely remov
ed through the use of a potassium iodide (KI) scrubber or denuder. How
ever, these devices were found to require modest water concentrations
(>4000 ppmv; RH > 10% at 25 degrees C) to remove ozone effectively. Wi
th the C-18 cartridges, the presence of ozone in the airstream produce
d a positive interference for the HCHO-hydrazone using standard analys
is techniques. These results suggest that under ambient conditions off
setting errors are possible with the use of C-18 cartridges, if ozone
removal devices are not used. However, with proper precautions, either
of these cartridges can be a highly effective means of measuring form
aldehyde and other carbonyl compounds in urban atmospheres.