Objectives. To evaluate whether the CAGE, MAST-G or an abnormally high
MCV are effective screening instruments for alcohol misuse and if not
to devise a new instrument. Design. Questionnaire survey of randomly
selected patients. Setting. Acute admission wards of two district gene
ral hospitals. Period. 9 months. Subjects. Randomly selected patients,
aged 65 and over, admitted as emergencies, Main outcome measures. Exc
essive alcohol intake, alcohol dependence. Results. The sensitivities
of the CAGE, MAST-G and an abnormally high MCV for excess alcohol inta
ke and alcohol abuse are low, ranging from 0.13 to 0.54. Conclusion. T
he results confirm previous UK studies which indicate that the CAGE an
d an abnormally high MCV are poor screening instruments for alcohol mi
suse in older patients and also indicate that the MAST-G is an insensi
tive screening instrument. A new two-step instrument with five questio
ns in total was generated. This requires further validation. (C) 1997
John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.