Women who entered Master of Divinity programs leading toward ordinatio
n in the 1970s were part of the first generation of women to enter Pro
testant ministry in large numbers. Utilizing a framework suggested by
the work of Everett Hughes on contradictions and dilemmas of status, t
his paper examines these women's experience of going first, of combini
ng gender and work in a new way, particularly in settings of congregat
ional ministry. The analysis is longitudinal based on interviews in th
e 1970s with a sample of 30 women then enrolled in a United Methodist
and a Lutheran seminary in the United States, and on interviews with t
he same sample of women 15 years later.