T. Anstadt et al., AFFECTIVE DYADIC BEHAVIOR, CORE CONFLICTUAL RELATIONSHIP THEMES, AND SUCCESS OF TREATMENT, Psychotherapy research, 7(4), 1997, pp. 397-417
In 11 brief therapeutic treatments, affective facial behavior of thera
pists and patients as well as the latter's Core Conflictual Relationsh
ip Themes (CCRTs) were investigated and related to treatment outcome.
It has been found that compensatory not reciprocal affective facial be
havior of the therapeutic dyad in the first session is indicative of s
uccess. A scale describing reciprocity vs. compensation in facial beha
vior correlated significantly positively with self-reports of outcome
and symptom change. Two psychoanalytic treatments, one with the highes
t reciprocity and least success fate and one with the highest success
rate and high compensation, were analyzed in detail according to the t
emporal development of affect exchange and narration through the cours
e of the complete treatment. In both therapies the frequency of narrat
ives were negatively correlated with the frequency of facial affects o
f the patient, so that the hypothesis of a parallel processing of affe
ctive facial behavior and narration could be ruled out. In the success
ful treatment, the therapist showed those affects during the narration
of the patient which could have been expected from the latter. A very
distinct temporal organization within the successful treatment includ
ing an enactment period, a period of instability, and a period of cons
olidation, contrasted with a homogenous distribution of affect in the
unsuccessful one. The relevance of these results for a theory of the t
herapeutic process is discussed.