Narcolepsy is a sleep disorder associated with HLA DR15 (DR2?) and DQB
10602.? We HLA typed 509 patients enrolled in a clinical trial for th
e drug modafinil and analyzed the results in relation to cataplexy, a
symptom of narcolepsy characterized by muscle weakness triggered by em
otions. The patients were tither subjects with cataplexy who had a mea
n sleep latency (SL) of less than 8 minutes and two or more sleep onse
t rapid eye movement (REM) periods (SOREMPs) during a multiple sleep l
atency test, or narcoleptic patients without cataplexy but with a mean
SL shorter than 5 minutes and two or more SOREMPs. The respective val
ues of DRB115 (DR2) and DQB1*0602 as markers for narcolepsy were firs
t compared in different ethnic groups and in patients with and without
cataplexy. DQB10602 was found to be a more sensitive marker for narc
olepsy than DRB115 across all ethnic groups. DBQ1*0602 frequency was
strikingly higher in patients with cataplexy versus patients without c
ataplexy (76.1% in 421 patients versus 40.9% in XX patients). Positivi
ty was highest in patients with severe cataplexy (94.8%) and progressi
vely decreased to 54.2% in patients with the mildest cataplexy. A volu
ntary 50-item questionnaire focusing on cataplexy was also analyzed in
212 of the 509 HLA-typed patients. Subjects with definite cataplexy a
s observed by an experienced clinician were more frequently HLA DQB10
602-positive than those with doubtful cataplexy, and the manifestation
s of cataplexy were clinically more typical in DQB10602-positive pati
ents. These results show that the HLA association is!, as tight as pre
viously reported (85-95%) when cataplexy is clinically ;typical or sev
ere. We also found that patients with mild. atypical, or no cataplexy
have a significantly increased DQB10602 frequency (40-60%) in compari
son with ethnically matched controls (24%). These results could be exp
lained bq; increased disease heterogeneity in the noncataplexy group o
r by a direct. effect of the HLA DQB1-0602 genotype on the clinical ex
pression of narcolepsy.