Rj. Anderson et al., HOLDFASTS OF ADULT KELP ECKLONIA-MAXIMA PROVIDE REFUGES FROM GRAZING FOR RECRUITMENT OF JUVENILE KELPS, Marine ecology. Progress series, 159, 1997, pp. 265-273
The distribution of young sporophytes (up to 0.25 m stipe length) of t
he kelp Ecklonia maxima, on various substrata, at depths of 2.5 to 5.0
m, was studied at 8 sites on the southwest coast of South Africa. The
most common substratum available was rock (bare or covered with encru
sting coralline algae), followed by kelp holdfasts, and the ascidian P
yura stolonifera at some sites. A disproportionately high ratio (relat
ive to the available substrata) of young sporophytes grew on the holdf
asts of mature kelps at most sites, but particularly where high densit
ies of benthic invertebrate grazers were present (mainly the urchin Pa
rechinus angulosus, also abalone Haliotis midae, limpets Patella spp,
and gastropods Turbo spp, and Oxystele spp.). Jacobs' index of electiv
ity was used an indicator of 'preference for' (interpreted as indicati
ng survival on) the substratum type. This showed a statistically signi
ficant 'negative selection' of rock as a substratum at sites where gra
zers were numerous. The ratios of young sporophytes on holdfasts/young
sporophytes on rock were directly proportional to grazer densities wh
en sites were compared (r = -0.90, p = 0.002); supporting the hypothes
is that mature holdfasts are an important refuge for recruitment of E.
maxima sporophytes. There was an inverse relationship between percent
age cover of understorey algae and grazer densities (r = 0.92, p = 0.0
01). In general, sites east of Cape Point (west coast/south coast tran
sition zone) have far more grazers and reduced understorey algal bioma
sses compared to west coast sites. There thus appear to be fundamental
differences in some of the major ecological processes in kelp beds in
these 2 areas, with important implications for commercial kelp harves
ting.