A foam model of a protrusio acetabulum with cylindrical voids of varyi
ng diameters was used to test acetabular components for their ability
to resist migration within the defect. A bipolar component, a hemisphe
rical cup, and a hemispherical cup with peripheral rim augmentation we
re tested in defects with diameters ranging from 1 to 3 mm less than t
he major diameter of the component. The cup with peripheral rim augmen
tation demonstrated 20% to 40% greater resistance to migration than th
e hemispherical cup, depending on the extent of under-reaming, with th
e bipolar component consistently demonstrating the lowest load to fail
ure. The results of this study confirm the less-than-satisfactory clin
ical results seen with bipolar reconstruction of protrusio acetabuli,
and support the use of ''fixed'' cups in these settings.