S. Carmel, MEDICAL-STUDENTS ATTITUDES REGARDING THE USE OF LIFE-SUSTAINING TREATMENTS FOR THEMSELVES AND FOR ELDERLY PERSONS, Social science & medicine, 46(4-5), 1998, pp. 467-474
Citations number
67
Categorie Soggetti
Social Sciences, Biomedical","Public, Environmental & Occupation Heath
This study investigated students' wishes regarding the use of life-sus
taining treatments (LST) in different health conditions compared with
their evaluations of the wishes of elderly people, and with reports of
a group of elderly people about themselves. Data were collected from
two consecutive classes of first year medical students (n = 101), and
a random sample of Israeli elderly aged 70+ (n = 987) who responded to
fixed-choice questions regarding their will to live and wishes for th
ree kinds of LST in a number of hypothetical illness conditions. The s
tudents were also asked to assess elderly's wishes. Students ranked th
e will to live of elderly persons significantly lower than their own.
The elderly ranked their will to live significantly lower than did the
students, but higher than the students assumed about them, indicating
that although the will to live is weaker among older people, it is st
ronger than young persons believe. With regard to the use of LST, stud
ents believe that old people want less LST than themselves, but the el
derly want even less LST than assumed by the students. The best predic
tors of students' wishes for themselves were fear of dying and religio
sity. Fear of dying, the students' self-esteem and religiosity were th
e best predictors of their evaluations of the elderly's wishes. The re
sults indicate that both the elderly and the students have a relativel
y strong will to live, but this desire is dependent on quality of life
. The implications of this study for medical education are discussed.
(C) 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.