If an economic time series behaves asymmetrically, then an interpretat
ion of economic fluctuations based on linear time-series models could
be misleading. Beaudry and Koop (1993) recently argued that for post-w
ar US GDP data there exists a statistically significant difference in
persistence between negative and positive shocks. We demonstrate that
their test has two pitfalls: First, the t-statistic for testing asymme
try in persistence does not have a conventional interpretation. Second
, a highly significant I-value may come from sources different from as
ymmetry. Using international data, we investigate for the presence of
asymmetric persistence across the G-7 countries. (C) 1997 Elsevier Sci
ence B.V. All rights reserved.