La. Nuttbrock et al., OUTCOMES OF HOMELESS MENTALLY-ILL CHEMICAL ABUSERS IN COMMUNITY RESIDENCES AND A THERAPEUTIC-COMMUNITY, Psychiatric services, 49(1), 1998, pp. 68-76
Objective: The feasibility and effectiveness of treating homeless ment
ally ill chemical abusers in community residences compared with a ther
apeutic community were evaluated. Methods: A total of 694 homeless men
tally ill chemical abusers were randomly referred to two community res
idences or a therapeutic community. All programs were enhanced to trea
t persons with dual diagnosis. Subjects' attrition, substance use, and
psychopathology were measured at two, six, and 12 months. Results: Fo
rty-two percent of the 694 referred subjects were admitted to their as
signed program and showed up for treatment, and 13 percent completed 1
2 months or more. Clients retained at both types of program showed red
uctions in substance use and psychopathology, but reductions were grea
ter at the therapeutic community. Compared with subjects in the commun
ity residences, those in the therapeutic community were more likely to
be drug free, as measured by urine analysis and self-reports, and sho
wed greater improvement in psychiatric symptoms, as measured by the Ce
nter for Epidemiological Studies-Depression Scale and the Brief Psychi
atric Rating Scale. Their functioning also improved, as measured by th
e Global Assessment of Functioning scale. Conclusion: Homeless mentall
y ill chemical abusers who are retained in community-based residential
programs, especially in therapeutic communities, can be successfully
treated.