2 COMPLEMENTARY BIOASSAYS FOR SCREENING THE ESTROGENIC POTENCY OF XENOBIOTICS - RECOMBINANT YEAST FOR TROUT ESTROGEN-RECEPTOR AND TROUT HEPATOCYTE CULTURES
F. Petit et al., 2 COMPLEMENTARY BIOASSAYS FOR SCREENING THE ESTROGENIC POTENCY OF XENOBIOTICS - RECOMBINANT YEAST FOR TROUT ESTROGEN-RECEPTOR AND TROUT HEPATOCYTE CULTURES, Journal of molecular endocrinology, 19(3), 1997, pp. 321-335
A relation between the chemical structure of a xenobiotic and its ster
oidal action has not yet been clearly established. Thus, it is not pos
sible to define the estrogenic potency of different xenobiotics. An as
sessment may be accomplished by the use of different bioassays. We hav
e previously developed a yeast system highly and stably expressing rai
nbow trout estrogen receptor (rtER) in order to analyze the biological
activity of the receptor. The recombinant yeast system appears to be
a reliable, rapid and sensitive bioassay for the screening and determi
nation of the direct interaction between ER and estrogenic compounds.
This system was used in parallel with a more elaborate biological syst
em, trout hepatocyte aggregate cultures, to examine the estrogenic pot
ency of a wide spectrum of chemicals commonly found in the environment
. In hepatocyte cultures, the vitellogenin gene whose expression is pr
incipally dependent upon estradiol was used as a biomarker. Moreover,
competitive binding assays were performed to determine direct interact
ion between rtER and xenobiotics. In our study, 50% of the 49 chemical
compounds tested exhibited estrogenic activity in the two bioassays:
the herbicide diclofop-methyl; the fungicides biphenyl, dodemorph, and
triadimefon; the insecticides lindane, methyl parathion, chlordecone,
dieldrin, and endosulfan; polychlorinated biphenyl mixtures; the plas
ticizers or detergents alkylphenols and phthalates; and phytoestrogens
. To investigate further biphenyl estrogenic activity, its principal m
etabolites were also tested in both bioassays. Among these estrogenic
compounds, 70% were able to activate rtER in yeast and hepatocytes wit
h variable induction levels according to the system. Nevertheless, 30%
of these estrogenic compounds exhibited estrogenic activity in only o
ne of the bioassays, suggesting the implication of metabolites or diff
erent pathways in the activation of gene transcription. This paper sho
ws that it is important to combine in vivo bioassays with in vitro app
roaches to elucidate the mechanism of xenoestrogen actions.