Dvm. Bishop, COGNITIVE NEUROPSYCHOLOGY AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISORDERS - UNCOMFORTABLEBEDFELLOWS, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology, 50(4), 1997, pp. 899-923
Cognitive neuropsychology provides a theoretical framework and methods
that can be of value in the study of developmental disorders, but the
''dissociation'' logic at the centre of this approach is not well sui
ted to the developmental context. This is illustrated with examples fr
om specific language impairment. Within the developing language system
there is ample evidence for interaction between levels of representat
ion, with modularity emerging in the course of development. This means
that one typically is seeking to explain a complex pattern of associa
ted impairments, rather than highly selective deficits. For instance,
a selective impairment in auditory processing can have repercussions t
hrough the language system and may lead to distinctive syntactic defic
its that are seen in written as well as spoken language. Changes in th
e nature of representations and in the relationships between component
s of a developing system mean that cross-sectional data at a single po
int in development may be misleading indicators of the primary deficit
. Furthermore, traditional cognitive neuropsychology places a dispropo
rtionate emphasis on representational (competence) deficits, with proc
essing (performance) deficits being relatively neglected. Methods for
distinguishing these two kinds of impairment are discussed, as well as
other approaches for elucidating the underlying nature of development
al disorders.