G. Lushai et al., HOST SELECTION BY WINGED SUMMER FEMALES OF THE APHID SITOBION-AVENAE, Entomologia experimentalis et applicata, 85(3), 1997, pp. 199-209
A total of 55 parthenogenetic lineages of the grain aphid, Sitobion av
enae F. were established from single clones collected from winter whea
t (agricultural host) and cocksfoot (natural host) at various location
s in southern Britain. RAPD-PCR profiles indicated that these lineages
consisted of at least 15 genetically distinct clones. Twenty winged i
ndividuals (alatae) of known weight were taken from each lineage and p
resented with a choice of wheat and cocksfoot hosts (with a total leaf
area each of 2 cm(2)) held in petri dishes (laboratory experiments) a
nd flowerpots (field experiments). In both experimental designs host p
references were determined by a ranking of a proportion of counts (lim
ited to -1 --> +1) of the progeny produced on each host after 5 days.
Overall, alatae tended to prefer the agricultural host. However, alata
e from individual clones found exclusively on wheat generally had a hi
gher preference for wheat than alatae from individual clones found exc
lusively on cocksfoot. Wheat-derived lineages (aphid genotypes that we
re collected on wheat but also present on cocksfoot) showed a signific
antly greater preference for the agricultural host than the cocksfoot-
derived lineages. Individuals from a wheat-derived lineage had signifi
cantly higher observed and potential progeny production on wheat than
they did on cocksfoot, while individuals from a cocksfoot-derived line
age had significantly higher potential progeny but lower mean progeny
weights on wheat. In a second stage, reciprocal host transfer experime
nts were carried out in the laboratory, i.e. lineages collected from t
he agricultural host were reared for several generations on the natura
l host and vice versa prior to being tested for host preference. The p
reference of the lineages for their host of origin significantly decre
ased in this second trial, reversing the overall preference trends, wh
ile there was little evidence for between-lineage variation in this ch
ange in preference. In summary these results indicate weak genotypic b
ut strong environmental influences on alate host preference in S. aven
ae. This host plant conditioning effect may serve to promote host-base
d genetic structuring observed in southern British populations of S. a
venae.