F. Crippa et al., PROSPECTIVE EVALUATION OF FLUORINE-18-FDG PET IN PRESURGICAL STAGING OF THE AXILLA IN BREAST-CANCER, The Journal of nuclear medicine, 39(1), 1998, pp. 4-8
Methods: The presurgical, noninvasive staging of axillary nodes for me
tastases was prospectively investigated in 68 patients who were diagno
sed with primary breast cancer using PET with F-18-fluorodeoxyglucose
(FDG). Four patients had bilateral nodules; therefore, the total numbe
r of evaluable cases was 72. Visual analyses of attenuation-corrected
PET images and standardized uptake values (SUVs) of FDG uptake in carc
inomas were compared with histopathological surgical findings. The SUV
distribution differences between carcinomas with and without axillary
metastases were evaluated by means of statistical and receiver operat
ing characteristics analyses. Results: PET correctly classified 64 of
the 72 cases; four false-positive and four false-negative PET results
were found. The overall sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of PET f
or axillary metastases were 85%, 91% and 89%, respectively. With respe
ct to the clinical axillary stage of the patients (TNM, or tumor-node-
metastasis, classification), we obtained the following results: N-o pa
tients, sensitivity = 70%, specificity = 92%, accuracy = 86%; N-1a pat
ients, sensitivity = 85.5%, specificity = 100%, accuracy = 95%; and N1
b-2 patients, sensitivity = 100%, specificity = 67%, accuracy = 87%. T
he median SUV in carcinomas with axillary metastases (4.6) was signifi
cantly higher than that in carcinomas without metastases (2.9), but th
ere was a great SUV overlap between the two groups (interquartile rang
es = 2.7-7.2 and 1.4-4.5, respectively), Analysis of the receiver oper
ating characteristics curve showed that a high sensitivity of SUV in p
redicting axillary metastases was associated with a very low specifici
ty and vice versa. With the best SUV cutoff value of 2.9, the sensitiv
ity and specificity were 74% and 56%, respectively, Conclusion: PET sh
owed good overall diagnostic accuracy in the detection of axillary met
astases (86%). The very high accuracy (95%) in N-1a patients is of par
ticular importance. False-negative PET findings, however, can be encou
ntered, SUVs of breast carcinoma cannot predict the spread of the dise
ase to the axilla, even if higher values are often associated with axi
llary metastases. Any decision on the use of PET in the presurgical st
aging of breast cancer should be incorporated into a more general deba
te on axillary management, In selected patients with a very low probab
ility of axillary metastases (T-1a), in whom axillary surgery can alre
ady be avoided according to data from follow-up studies, F-18-FDG PET
could be proposed as a noninvasive imaging modality to improve the dia
gnosis of axillary relapses.