Wb. Worthen et al., COMMUNITY STRUCTURE AND ENVIRONMENTAL-STRESS - DESICCATION PROMOTES NESTEDNESS IN MYCOPHAGOUS FLY COMMUNITIES, Oikos, 81(1), 1998, pp. 45-54
In a previous field experiment, communities of mycophagous flies that
emerged from Agaricus bisporus mushrooms exhibited a nested-subset pat
tern related to mushroom size. A phorid species and Leucophenga varia
(Drosophilidae) emerged from small, medium, and large mushrooms, but o
ther drosophilid species were usually limited to large mushrooms. Here
, we conducted two experiments and one field survey to determine wheth
er this nestedness pattern is caused by nested desiccation tolerances
among species, coupled with the mediating effects of mushroom size. In
the first experiment, 20 first instar larvae of either Drosophila tri
punctata or D. putrida were added to A. bisporus mushrooms that weighe
d 5 g, 10 g, or 20 g. Mushrooms were placed in environmental chambers
at different temperatures for 5 d (maxima of 25 degrees C, 30 degrees
C, or 35 degrees C). Both mushroom size and temperature had significan
t direct effects on the proportion of larvae completing development; l
arvae in small mushrooms are more susceptible to desiccation stress th
an larvae in large mushrooms. In a second experiment, we examined the
effect of desiccation stress on community structure. Woodland mushroom
s collected in the field were cut in half; the halves were placed at d
ifferent incubation temperatures (maxima of either 25 degrees C or 35
degrees C) for 5 d, and emerging flies were counted and sorted by spec
ies. The halves incubated at 35 degrees C produced significantly neste
d communities, the halves incubated at 25 degrees C did not. Correlati
ons between fly abundance and mushroom mass were also more significant
at higher temperatures. These results were consistent with the hypoth
esis that desiccation stress, differentially mediated by mushroom size
, drives nested subset structure in these communities. In a four-week
field survey, however, nestedness was not related to mean temperature
or rainfall. We contend that small habitats are less resistant to chan
ges in environmental conditions than larger habitats, so the intensity
of environmental stress will correlate with habitat size. So, some in
itially variable and non-nested communities might decay to a nested-su
bset pattern of species composition as a result of differential habita
t buffering under stressful environmental conditions.