Sp. Roose et al., COMPARISON OF PAROXETINE AND NORTRIPTYLINE IN DEPRESSED-PATIENTS WITHISCHEMIC-HEART-DISEASE, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 279(4), 1998, pp. 287-291
Context.-Depression and ischemic heart disease often are comorbid cond
itions and, in patients who have had a myocardial infarction, the pres
ence of depression is associated with increased mortality. Patients wi
th heart disease need a safe and effective treatment for depression. O
bjective.-To compare the efficacy, cardiovascular effects, and safety
of a specific serotonin reuptake inhibitor, paroxetine, with a tricycl
ic antidepressant, nortriptyline hydrochloride, in depressed patients
with ischemic heart disease. Design.-Two-week placebo lead-in followed
by a double-blind randomized 6-week medication trial. Setting.-Resear
ch clinics in 4 university centers. Patients.-Eighty-one outpatients m
eeting Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth E
dition criteria for major depressive disorder and with documented isch
emic heart disease. Interventions.-Treatment with either paroxetine, 2
0 to 30 mg/d, or nortriptyline targeted to a therapeutic plasma level,
190 to 570 nmol/L (50-150 ng/mL), for 6 weeks. Main Outcome Measures.
-For effectiveness of treatment, a decline in the score of the Hamilto
n Rating Scale for Depression by 50% and final score of 8 or less; for
cardiovascular safety, heart rate and rhythm, supine and standing sys
tolic and diastolic blood pressures, electrocardiogram conduction inte
rvals, indexes of heart rate variability, and rate of adverse events.
Results.-By intent-to-treat analysis, 25 (61%) of 41 patients improved
during treatment with paroxetine and 22 (55%) of 40 improved with nor
triptyline. Neither drug significantly affected blood pressure or cond
uction intervals. Paroxetine had no sustained effects on heart rate or
rhythm or indexes of heart rate variability, whereas patients treated
with nortriptyline had a sustained 11% increase in heart rate from a
mean of 75 to 83 beats per minute (P<.001) and a reduction in heart ra
te variability, as measured by the SD of all normal R-R intervals over
a 24-hour period, from 112 to 96 (P<.01). Adverse cardiac events occu
rred in 1 (2%) of 41 patients treated with paroxetine and 7 (18%) of 4
0 patients treated with nortriptyline (P<.03). Conclusions.-Paroxetine
and nortriptyline are effective treatments for depressed patients wit
h ischemic heart disease. Nortriptyline treatment was associated with
a significantly higher rate of serious adverse cardiac events compared
with paroxetine.