P. Guigui et al., LONG-TERM OSSEOUS MODIFICATION OF THE POS TERIOR ARCH AFTER DECOMPRESSIVE SURGERY FOR LUMBAR SPINAL STENOSIS, Revue de chirurgie orthopedique et reparatrice de l'appareil moteur, 83(8), 1997, pp. 697-706
Purpose of the study Many studies have indicated favorable results of
decompressive surgery for symptomatic lumbar spinal stenosis. However,
little is known about the osseous changes that occur at the operative
sites. Postacchini in 1992 and Chen in 1994 have studied, only from p
lain radiographs, osseous changes at the operative sites, and have sug
gested that bone regrowth possibly affects the neurologic result. The
aims of this study were: to assess bone regrowth at the operative site
, to compare the bone regrowth rate calculated from plain radiographs
and CT-Scan examinations, to determine the effects of bone regrowth on
clinical outcome, to investigate the factors promoting the bone regro
wth. Material and method 28 patients who underwent decompressive surge
ry for lumbar spinal stenosis were retrospectively studied with an ave
rage follow-up of 8.4 years. In order to evaluate the degree of bone r
egrowth at the posterior arch, early postoperative radiographs and CT
images of the operative sites were compared with those obtained at fin
al follow-up. Bone regrowth at the sites operated upon was evaluated a
s a percentage of regrowth of the original laminectomy site based upon
plain radiographs and CT images. Results Decompressive lumbar spinal
stenosis is responsible for bone regrowth at the operative site in mos
t patients. However, this regrowth was mild, the mean bone regrowth ra
te evaluated from plain radiographs was 12 per cent In average and the
obtained from CT images was 8,2 per Gent in average. Changes were fou
nd to be predominant at the facet joint level compared to the pedicle
level. The evaluation of regrowth obtained from plain films and CT ima
ge examinations were compared. Radiographs seem to overestimate bone r
egrowth. Postoperative spinal instability was statistically significan
tly associated with new bone development. This variable was the only f
actor that affected the degree of bone regrowth. No relationship betwe
en bone regrowth and clinical outcome was found. Discussion and conclu
sion Natural course of laminectomy defect includes probably new bone f
ormation in most patients. New bone results from gradual regrowth of t
he laminae and articular processes partially resected at surgery and f
rom coalescence of islets of bone tissue within the tissue filling the
laminectomy defect. In the present study bone regrowth rate was moder
ate but in other ones it was marked. If some factors (like postoperati
ve destabilization) promoting bone regrowth were identified many remai
n unknown. Factors influencing rapidity of regrowth progression remain
also unknown. Patient's intrinsic features such as spinal stenosis ch
aracteristics are probably closely related to quantitiative and kineti
c characteristics of regrowth. Consequences of bone regrowth are also
variable: in some cases regrowth may reproduce pathological conditions
identical previous ones, in other ones new bone spreads around the du
ra a mater without any nerves roots compression. Study of bone regrowt
h requires further research including prospective studies and using a
more precise method for the regrowth evaluation.