Tp. Carpenter et al., A LONGITUDINAL-STUDY OF INVENTION AND UNDERSTANDING IN CHILDRENS MULTIDIGIT ADDITION AND SUBTRACTION, Journal for research in mathematics education, 29(1), 1998, pp. 3-20
This 3-year longitudinal study investigated the development of 82 chil
dren's understanding of multidigit number concepts and operations in G
rades 1-3. Students were individually interviewed 5 times on a variety
of tasks involving base-ten number concepts and addition and subtract
ion problems. The study provides an existence proof that children can
invent strategies for adding and subtracting and illustrates both what
that invention affords and the role that different concepts may play
in that invention. About 90% of the students used invented strategies.
Students who used invented strategies before they learned standard al
gorithms demonstrated better knowledge of base-ten number concepts and
were more successful in extending their knowledge to new situations t
han were students who initially learned standard algorithms.