The existing literature finds that price discrepancy, which represents
the difference between expected and observed price, helps explain bra
nd choice and purchase intention. This effect is often attributed to t
ransaction utility, that is, the incremental utility associated with t
he surprise of observing a price lower or higher than expected. This r
esearch considers the possibility, however that transaction utility is
a less important determinant of choice when quality is uncertain. We
propose and find that acquisition utility (perceived value for the mon
ey) tends to dominate the explanation of purchase intention, but trans
action utility is significant only when consumers are more certain abo
ut quality. Our discussion considers the relative role of transaction
utility in explaining consumer decision making and how the informative
and allocative roles of price might be distinguished.