Frederick Turner argues in The Culture of Hope that avant-garde attitu
des have become obsolete, inhibiting, and altogether blind to the crea
tive possibilities of the future, with its new science and technology
and triumphant capitalism. Paradoxically, Turner argues, the cultural
future in volves a regression to a classical spirit, indeed, to tradit
ional modes of representation and a new religiosity. But Turner has so
ld avant-garde achievement short, even misrepresented it, however corr
ect his analysis and assessment of its current character. He has also
overestimated capitalism and religion, and his paradigm deploys cliche
s of decadence and renewal in a Manichean struggle. While his hopefuln
ess is admirable, it is tragically inadequate.