Ib. Mandell et al., EFFECTS OF DIET, BREED AND SLAUGHTER END-POINT ON GROWTH-PERFORMANCE,CARCASS COMPOSITION AND BEEF QUALITY TRAITS IN LIMOUSIN AND CHAROLAISSTEERS, Canadian journal of animal science, 77(1), 1997, pp. 23-32
Ninety-six Charolais and Limousin steers were used to evaluate 75% gra
in (whole barley or corn) diets and two slaughter endpoints (7 mm back
fat or 568 kg liveweight) in an experiment designed to constrain carca
ss weights to under approximately 341 kg yet produce optimal beef qual
ity. Each breed was represented by eight progeny from each of six sire
s. The trial was terminated after 281 d feeding regardless of individu
al steers attaining designated slaughter endpoints. Limited availabili
ty of dietary energy in whole-barley diets resulted in decreased (P <
0.01) average daily gain and increased (P < 0.01) dry matter intake, f
eed/gain and days on feed for barley- vs, corn-fed cattle. Charolais o
utgained (P < 0.05) Limousin but dry matter intake was similar on a g
BW0(0.75) basis. Feeding to 568 kg liveweight was associated with high
(P < 0.10) ADG and decreased (P < 0.05) feed/gain compared with feedi
ng to 7 mm. Corn feeding increased (P < 0.001) carcass weights, fat de
position and longissimus muscle area. Lean deposition was greater (P <
0.01) in Limousin than Charolais. Taste panel assessment of tendernes
s, flavour and juiciness in longissimus muscle was generally not affec
ted (P > 0.10) by diet, breed or slaughter endpoint. Twelve primal rib
s from each of Agriculture Canada's marbling classifications (A, AA, A
AA) were purchased and processed identically to ribs from the test cat
tle. Shear and tenderness scores were similar (P > 0.10) across test c
attle and purchased ribs, despite intramuscular fat contents of 20.2,
27.1, 35.6 and 49.7 g kg(-1), respectively, for test cattle and trace,
slight and small marbled ribs. Slight and small marbled ribs did have
higher (P < 0.05) taste panel scores for initial juiciness and flavou
r than ribs from the test cattle. While 26% of carcasses from test cat
tle graded Canada B1 due to either inadequate finish or marbling, simi
lar tenderness and shear scores were probably due to age of test cattl
e at slaughter which averaged 481 +/- 45 d plus the fact that all roas
ts were aged 7 d prior to freezing.