Dl. Strout et Mb. Hall, STRUCTURE AND STABILITY OF LANTHANUM-CARBON CATIONS, The journal of physical chemistry. A, Molecules, spectroscopy, kinetics, environment, & general theory, 102(3), 1998, pp. 641-645
A theoretical study has been carried out to determine the stability of
various isomers of the lanthanum(-) carbon clusters LaCx+. Included i
n this study are linear isomers and several classes of cyclic and grap
hitic structures. Geometries and energies of the proposed structures a
re calculated using the B3LYP density functional method. Cyclic isomer
s are clearly established as more stable than linear isomers over a wi
de range of cluster sizes. The results reveal that two classes of cycl
ic isomers, which we denote ''open rings'' and ''closed rings'', have
a pattern of relative thermodynamic stability that correlates to the p
attern of cluster intensities in the ion mobility observations of the
LaCx+ clustering process. The competitive factors that provide stabili
ty to lanthanum-carbon clusters are elucidated, such as ring strain an
d variations in the lanthanum bonding environment. Graphitic LaCx+ wit
h 18 or 20 carbon atoms are shown to be more stable than their cyclic
counterparts, and B3LYP is shown to underestimate the stability of gra
phitic LaCx+.