Jl. Patry et F. Hofmann, PERSONAL AUTONOMY AS EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIV E - ASPIRATION AND REALITY, PSYCHOLOGIE IN ERZIEHUNG UND UNTERRICHT, 45(1), 1998, pp. 53-66
After a clarification of the notion of personal autonomy it is shown t
hat the gap between the ideals of education (educational objectives) a
nd the daily teaching practice has remained largely unexplored. The pr
esent study is focused upon the exploration of this gap and deals with
the question how much teachers would like to achieve the educational
objectives ,,self determination'' and ,,social responsibility'' (educa
tion to personal autonomy) and in which extent they try to db so in th
e daily practice. A comparison between the ideal of education and the
daily practice demonstrates that the gap is more important in the fiel
d of personal autonomy with respect to the mediation of knowledge and
skills and with respect to keeping the discipline: The objectives of p
ersonal autonomy are aspired in a strong way, but in realization they
do not differ from the other educational objectives. There are differe
nces depending on the subject matters. It is also investigated which k
inds of teaching methods are used by the teachers to achieve students'
autonomy. It is shown that teachers dispose of the necessary repertoi
re of teaching methods and that they use these methods - the more they
esteem the objectives of personal autonomy the sooner. Finally the qu
estion is asked if and in which situations teachers reflect on values
and educational objectives. According to their answers those reflectio
ns occur surprisingly often. Once more it is shown that there is a sig
nificant correlation between the frequency of reflections on education
al objectives and the tendency of aspiration of realizing the objectiv
e of personal autonomy. The results serve as a basis for the discussio
n of questions concerning the organisation of schools and for concepts
of teacher training.