We present a comparison between the predictions of two theoretical mod
els and experimental results on ultrathin GaAs layers with a thickness
in the range from 1 to 8 ML embedded in bulk (AlxGa1-x)As, 0.30 less
than or equal to x less than or equal to 0.34. The theoretical predict
ions, obtained from an empirical tight-binding Green's-function approa
ch and from the usual effective-mass approximation, are compared to ph
otoluminescence and photoluminescence excitation data of a set of mult
iple quantum-well samples grown by metal-organic vapor-phase epitaxy o
n substrates with different misorientations. We find that the optical
transitions are narrower in samples with slightly misoriented substrat
es, although their spectral position remains unchanged. This suggests
that the substrate misorientation favors a good quality of the ternary
alloy. The observed optical transitions of our thin layers compare we
ll with the predictions of both models. However, the lack of a reliabl
e exciton theory for such ultrathin layers becomes apparent.