PREDATOR-PREY INTERACTIONS BETWEEN THE NATICIDS EUSPIRA-HEROS SAY ANDNEVERITA-DUPLICATA SAY AND THE ATLANTIC SURFCLAM SPISULA-SOLIDISSIMA DILLWYN FROM LONG-ISLAND TO DELAWARE
Gp. Dietl et Rr. Alexander, PREDATOR-PREY INTERACTIONS BETWEEN THE NATICIDS EUSPIRA-HEROS SAY ANDNEVERITA-DUPLICATA SAY AND THE ATLANTIC SURFCLAM SPISULA-SOLIDISSIMA DILLWYN FROM LONG-ISLAND TO DELAWARE, Journal of shellfish research, 16(2), 1997, pp. 413-422
Interactions between the naticids Euspira heros (Say, 1822) and Neveri
ta duplicata (Say, 1822) and their prey, the Atlantic surfclam Spisula
solidissima (Dillwyn, 1817), were reconstructed from 1,300 bored shel
ls collected at six localities from Long Island to Delaware. Both nati
cids show comparable site selectivity on prey valves, with 90% of comp
lete boreholes from any one locality situated in the umbonal region, s
lightly posterior to the dorsoventral axis. Variation in complete bore
hole location in biaxial scattergrams was least for the N. duplicata-a
ffected locality in Great Egg Harbor. Incomplete boreholes show a simi
lar distribution to complete boreholes, which suggests that failure to
penetrate the shell was not a consequence of poor siting of the drill
hole. Modal frequency of boreholes occurs in valves between 20 and 59
mm in anteroposterior width, with a size refuge from predation at widt
hs greater than 120 mm, although unbored specimens reached a maximum w
idth of 160 mm. Mean borehole diameter is greatest (5.7 mm) for the E.
he,os-affected northernmost sample from Fire Island Inlet, NY, and le
ast (3.3 mm) for the N. duplicata-affected Fenwick Island, DE, sample.
In addition to possible taxonomic differences in radula size between
naticid species, older and younger cohorts (age classes) may dominate
the northern and southern naticid populations, respectively. Regressio
ns of outer borehole diameter (OBD) on prey valve width indicate that
naticids were prey size selective, although the degree of correlation
varies significantly from E. heros-affected Barnegat Inlet (r = 0.81)
to N. duplicata-affected Great Egg Harbor Inlet (r = 0.33) samples. Hi
gh versus low correlations indicate few versus many predator-prey mism
atches, i.e., oversized or undersized OBDs relative to surfclam valve
width. Variation in prey size selectivity is attributed to age (size)-
class dominance, or lack of among contiguous populations of surfclams
and naticids. Significantly lower correlation coefficients,based on fi
eld death assemblages relative to published statistics based on natici
d predation in captivity are attributed to stochastically interrupted
foraging of moonsnails on disturbance-prone exposed tidal flats versus
disturbance-minimized aquarium experiments. Slopes of regression line
s from E. heros-affected samples show a rate of increase in OBD with i
ncreasing clam prey width that is three times that of the N. duplicata
-affected Great Egg Harbor sample. Prey effectiveness, indexed by the
ratio of valves with incomplete to total attempted boreholes, is 0.01
for Fenwick Island, a surfclam population dominated by young cohorts,
to 0.22 for Barnegat Inlet, a population with many old-aged individual
s.