Kw. Butzer et Ek. Butzer, THE NATURAL VEGETATION OF THE MEXICAN BAJIO - ARCHIVAL DOCUMENTATION OF A 16TH-CENTURY SAVANNA ENVIRONMENT, Quaternary international, 43-4, 1997, pp. 161-172
Neo-ecologists make assumptions about a 'natural' or potential vegetat
ion when they argue whether a particular landscape is in secondary and
degraded condition. Similarly, paleoecologists attempt to infer a thr
ee-dimensional biotic mosaic from a core taken in a low-lying wetland.
Yet with millennia of human disturbance, climatic fluctuation, biotic
response to long-term climatic trends or catastrophic 'events', and c
oevolution between Holocene vegetation and human land-use,;natural eco
systems' have not been in equilibrium. While past vegetation changes c
an be traced, efforts to reconstruct potential vegetation are probably
unrealistic. This paper assembles 16th century landscape descriptions
of the Bajio of Central Mexico from archival repositories, to charact
erise the landscape at the time of Spanish intrusion. Attention is foc
used on five major landscape elements: (1) Riparian woodlands of mesqu
ite, bald cypress and willow, with reed stands; (2) Level, vertisolic
plains, with a low-tree savanna (mesquite acacia-grass); (3) Steeper p
iedmont plains with stony substrates, probably favoring xeric, thorn-b
ush associations; (4) Rough uplands with a mix of mesquite-acacia wood
land, scrub oak, and them bush; and (5) Mountains dominated by live an
d deciduous oak woodlands. The biotic mosaic of the 16th century appea
rs similar to that of the modern spontaneous vegetation in physiognomi
c terms, despite changes in structure. Areas of older indigenous settl
ement were affected by local vegetation disturbance, with partial defo
restation near lakes Cuitzeo and Yuriria. While Spanish-Criollo intrus
ion (1540-1640) brought new, potentially destructive landuse methods,
there is no evidence of additional landscape degradation in the Bajio
until well into the 18th century. Dramatic changes in hydrology and ri
parian vegetation are quite recent. Archival documentation provides a
complementary methodology to re-examine the interplay of edaphic varia
tion, climate and cumulative land-use in understanding contemporary ve
getation, and it can assist in converting proxy data into a three-dime
nsional landscape. (C) 1997 INQUA/Elsevier Science Ltd.