Vj. Warburton et al., CLINICAL AND HISTOLOGICAL ASSOCIATIONS OF CAGA AND VACA GENOTYPES IN HELICOBACTER-PYLORI GASTRITIS, Journal of Clinical Pathology, 51(1), 1998, pp. 55-61
Aims-To determine the relation among the cytotoxin associated gene (ca
gA) and vacuolating cytotoxin gene (vacA) status of Helicobacter pylor
i isolates, the associated clinical diseases, and the severity and pat
tern of chronic gastritis. Methods-Helicobacter pylori was cultured fr
om gastric biopsies obtained from dyspeptic patients. DNA was extracte
d from the isolates and the cagA and vacA status determined by the pol
ymerase chain reaction (PCR). The prevalence of the different cagA and
vacA genotypes in three clinical groups, duodenal ulcer, gastric ulce
r, and non-ulcer dyspepsia was compared. The histological features in
sections from two antral and two corpus biopsies were graded by one bl
inded observer. The grades were compared with age and sex matched grou
ps with different cagA and vacA genotypes, and with duodenal ulcers, o
r non-ulcer dyspepsia. Results-Isolates from 161 patients were include
d. One hundred and nine (68%) harboured a cagA+ strain and 143 (89%) h
arboured a vacA sl strain. The prevalence of cagA+ strains in duodenal
ulcer patients (94%) was highly significantly greater than in those w
ith non-ulcer dyspepsia (56%). However, of the patients infected with
a cagA+ strain, almost equal numbers had non-ulcer dyspepsia or peptic
ulceration. Chronic inflammation, polymorph activity, surface epithel
ial degeneration, atrophy, and intestinal metaplasia were all signific
antly more severe in the cagA+ than in the cagA- group, whereas only c
orpus epithelial degeneration was significantly more severe in the vac
A sl group compared with the vacA s2 group. Patients infected with cag
A+ strains were almost four times more Likely to have antral intestina
l metaplasia than cagA- patients. An antral predominant gastritis was
present in duodenal ulcer patients compared with matched nonulcer dysp
epsia patients, but this was not attributable to cagA or vacA status.
Conclusions-Helicobacter pylori strains showing cagA positivity and th
e vacA sl genotype are associated with more severe gastritis but these
virulence factors do not appear to determine the overall pattern. The
pattern is closely linked to clinical disease. Therefore, it is likel
y that the nature of the disease complicating chronic infection is det
ermined by host and environmental factors, while bacterial factors det
ermine the magnitude of the risk of developing such disease.