Ph. Thrall et J. Antonovics, POLYMORPHISM IN SEXUAL VERSUS NONSEXUAL DISEASE TRANSMISSION, Proceedings - Royal Society. Biological Sciences, 264(1381), 1997, pp. 581-587
Pathogens causing sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) often consist o
f related strains that cause nonsexually transmitted, or 'ordinary inf
ectious', diseases (OIDs). We use differential equation models of sing
le populations to derive conditions under which a genetic variant with
one (e.g. sexual) transmission mode can invade and successfully displ
ace a genetic variant with a different (e.g. non-sexual) transmission
mode. Invasion by an STD is easier if the equilibrium population size
in the presence of an OID is smaller; conversely an OID can invade mor
e easily if the equilibrium size of the population with the STD is lar
ger. Invasion of an STD does not depend on the degree of sterility cau
sed by the infection, but does depend on the added mortality caused by
a resident OID. In contrast, the ability of an OID to invade a popula
tion at equilibrium with an STD decreases as the degree of sterility c
aused by the STD increases. When equilibrium population sizes for a po
pulation infected with an STD are above the point at which non-sexual
contacts exceed sexual contacts (the sexual-social crossover point) an
d when equilibrium population sizes for an OID are below this point, t
here can be a stable genetic polymorphism for transmission mode. This
is most likely when the STD is mildly sterilizing, and the OID causes
low or intermediate levels of added mortality. Because we assume the s
trains are competitively equivalent and there are no heterogeneities a
ssociated with the transmission process, the polymorphism is maintaine
d by density-dependent selection brought about by pathogen effects on
population size.