A. Trinchieri et al., A STUDY OF DIETARY CALCIUM AND OTHER NUTRIENTS IN IDIOPATHIC RENAL CALCIUM STONE FORMERS WITH LOW BONE-MINERAL CONTENT, The Journal of urology, 159(3), 1998, pp. 654-657
Purpose: Patients with calcium renal stone are reported to have lower
bone mineral density. The state of bone density in patients with renal
stones have different explanations but the role of nutritional factor
s seems to be crucial. A group of 48 consecutive male calcium renal st
one formers was studied to investigate the relationship between bone d
ensity and dietary intake. Materials and Methods: Patients completed a
dietary diary for a 3-day period during normal diet. Nutrients and ca
lories were calculated by food composition tables using a computerized
procedure. Bone densitometry was assessed at the lumbar spine and fem
oral neck, and expressed as Z score. A blood sample was collected and
was analyzed for serum biochemistry including alkaline phosphatase, pa
rathyroid hormone and 1,25 vitamin D. A 24-hour urine sample was analy
zed for calcium, phosphate, oxalate, citrate and other electrolytes. R
esults: Dietary calcium intake was significantly lower (p < 0.01) in p
atients with low than in those with normal bone mineral density. There
was no difference in serum parathyroid hormone levels, phosphate and
alkaline phosphatase between the 2 groups. The results suggest that so
me renal stone formers seem to be unable to decrease renal excretion o
f calcium on a low calcium diet leading to a negative calcium balance.
Conclusions: A primary abnormality of bone metabolism could be a reas
onable explanation of reduced bone density observed in renal stone for
mers on a low calcium diet since serum parathyroid hormone levels are
in the normal range. From a therapeutic point of view these data confi
rm that restriction of dairy products in renal stone formers should be
avoided.