Td. Borkovec et Lg. Castonguay, WHAT IS THE SCIENTIFIC MEANING OF EMPIRICALLY SUPPORTED THERAPY, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology, 66(1), 1998, pp. 136-142
It is important to define precisely what is and is not meant by ''empi
rically supported treatments,'' rigorously based on what is actually k
nown about the nature of experimental therapy research, The criteria f
or empirically supported treatments merely allow conclusions about whe
ther treatments cause any change beyond the causative effect of such f
actors as placebo or the passage of time, Applied implications are lim
ited, due to external validity and to the fact that applied decisions
are influenced by cost-benefit analyses. Creating increasingly effecti
ve therapies through between-group designs is best done by controlled
trials specifically aimed at basic questions about the nature of psych
ological problems and the nature of therapeutic change mechanisms. Nat
uralistic research is important for external validity but is valuable
only if it uses scientifically valid methods to address basic knowledg
e questions.