Ls. Turkstra et Al. Holland, ASSESSMENT OF SYNTAX AFTER ADOLESCENT BRAIN INJURY - EFFECTS OF MEMORY ON TEST-PERFORMANCE, Journal of speech language and hearing research, 41(1), 1998, pp. 137-149
In this study, we investigated the influence of working memory load on
performance of a task designed to measure receptive syntax ability Su
bjects were 6 brain-injured adolescents and 6 hospitalized control sub
jects matched for age, sex, and general ability Each subject was admin
istered the Listening/Grammar subtest of the Test of Adolescent Langua
ge (TOAL-3) and a modified version of this subtest with identical synt
ax and fewer response choices [i.e., a reduced working memory processi
ng and storage load). The syntactic structures tested on these tasks a
lso were measured in spontaneous narratives. The brain-injured subject
s' performance was significantly worse than that of controls on both v
ersions of the syntax comprehension subtest. There was a significant g
roup-by-task interaction, as brain-injured subjects' performance was s
ignificantly worse on the Listening/Grammar subtest than the modified
subtest, whereas Control subjects' performance did not differ across t
he two tasks. In their spontaneous narratives, subjects in both groups
produced the syntactic structures tested on the receptive syntax task
s, with no between-groups difference in syntax production. The results
are discussed in terms of test validity and the impact of measurement
methods on test performance in disordered groups.