Hi. Pass et al., PREOPERATIVE TUMOR VOLUME IS ASSOCIATED WITH OUTCOME IN MALIGNANT PLEURAL MESOTHELIOMA, Journal of thoracic and cardiovascular surgery, 115(2), 1998, pp. 310-317
Objectives: Our objective was to analyze the impact of preoperative an
d postresection solid tumor volumes on outcomes in 47 of 48 consecutiv
e patients undergoing resection for malignant pleural mesothelioma who
were treated prospectively and randomized to photodynamic therapy or
no photodynamic therapy. Methods: From July 1993 to June 1996, 48 pati
ents with malignant pleural mesothelioma had cytoreductive debulking t
o 5 mm or less residual tumor by extrapleural pneumonectomy (n = 25) o
r pleurectomy/decortication (n = 23). Three-dimensional computed tomog
raphic reconstructions of preresection and postresection solid tumor w
ere prospectively performed and the disease was staged postoperatively
according to the new International Mesothelioma Interest Group stagin
g. Results: Median survival for all patients is 14.4 months (extrapleu
ral pneumonectomy, 11 months; pleurectomy/decortication, 22 months; p(
2) = 0.07), Median survival for preoperative volume less than 100 was
22 months versus 11 months if more than 100 cc, p(2) = 0.03, Median su
rvival for postoperative volume less than 9 cc was 25 months versus 9
months if more than 9 cc, p(2) = 0.0002. Thirty-two of forty-seven (68
%) had positive N1 or N2 nodes. Tumor volumes associated with negative
nodes were significantly smaller (median 51 cc) than those with posit
ive nodes (median 166 cc, p(2) = 0.01), Progressively higher stage was
associated with higher median preoperative volume: stage I, 4 cc; sta
ge II, 94 cc; stage III, 143 cc; stage IV, 505 cc; p(2) = 0.007 for st
age I versus II versus III versus IV. Patients with preoperative tumor
volumes greater than 52 cc had shorter progression-free intervals (8
months) than those 51 cc or less (11 months; p(2) = 0.02). Conclusions
: Preresection tumor volume is representative of T status in malignant
pleural mesothelioma and can predict overall and progression-free sur
vival, as well as postoperative stage. Large volumes are associated, w
ith nodal spread, and postresection residual tumor burden may predict
outcome.