Objective: Whether a chest radiograph should be performed routinely in
all infants after extubation, or selectively only in those with clini
cal deterioration, is a controversy in neonatal unit practice. This st
udy tested the hypothesis that most cases of post-extubation radiologi
cal deterioration in the lungs could be detected by clinical assessmen
t. Methods: A chest radiograph was performed at 8 h post-extubation in
100 episodes of extubation in 85 newborn infants ventilated for a var
iety of lung diseases. Each infant was assessed at the same time by a
neonatologist blinded to the radiological findings, to determine wheth
er a chest radiograph would have been requested based on clinical judg
ement. The infants were continuously monitored for their respiratory a
nd oxygenation status before and after extubation. Results: Compared t
o the pre-extubation chest radiographs, 23 of the 100 post-extubation
chest radiographs showed either deterioration of the pre-existing lung
pathologies or appearance of significant new pathologies. The clinici
ans' assessment failed to detect most of the deterioration, with a sen
sitivity of only 21.7%. Systematic analysis of the infants' clinical p
arameters showed that the development of significant intercostal/subco
stal retraction, and an increase in inspired oxygen concentration by g
reater than or equal to 7% after extubation, were the best predictors
of post-extubation radiological deterioration (sensitivity 82.6%, spec
ificity 62.3%, positive predictive value 39.6%, and negative predictiv
e value 92.3%). Serial blood gas in contrast had little predictive val
ue. Conclusion: We conclude that most cases of radiological deteriorat
ion of the lungs after extubation are clinically predictable, provided
the correct clinical criteria are used.