Combining and processing the information in ten previously published s
tudies, we analyse the Lucas variability hypotheses. When adequate acc
ount is taken of structural differences between developing and develop
ed countries, the prediction of the Lucas model that higher nominal de
mand variability leads to a lower inflation-output trade-off must be r
ejected for the group of developed countries. This does not imply that
developed countries can use active demand policies without deteriorat
ing their short-run inflation-output trade-off. More realistically, th
e result suggests that nominal demand variability is an inadequate ind
icator of demand shocks for the group of developed countries. This may
be due to relatively low inflation levels and variability in the deve
loped countries. For the developing countries where nominal (inflation
ary) shocks dominate, this may be less of a problem.