Interspecific brood amalgamation in waterfowl has been hypothesized to
be an extension of intraspecific brood amalgamation behavior that inc
reases the likelihood of successful amalgamation by increasing the ran
ge of potential recipients. I tested this hypothesis using recent phyl
ogenetic information. The analysis revealed that the likelihood that a
lineage carries the interspecific brood amalgamation state increases
significantly when the lineage also carries the intraspecific amalgama
tion state, thus supporting the hypothesis. The likelihood of a transi
tion to interspecific brood amalgamation was similar across categories
of several ecological and life-history factors, including nesting dis
persion, nesting substrate, type of brood care, and level of reproduct
ive effort. Nevertheless, several lineages carrying the intraspecific
brood amalgamation state failed to show the interspecific counterpart
suggesting that the expression of interspecific brood amalgamation ten
dencies can be constrained by other factors.