Gj. Hall et al., INCREASED ILLNESS EXPERIENCE PRECEDING CHRONIC-FATIGUE-SYNDROME - A CASE-CONTROL STUDY, Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of London, 32(1), 1998, pp. 44-48
Background: Almost all published work on chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS
) has involved retrospective surveys of cases, which may introduce rec
all bias. Only medical records collected before diagnosis of CFS fan e
liminate this. Methods: Using data collected several years prior to th
e development of the illness, we performed a case control study, compa
ring the reported illness records of all people who subsequently made
an insurance claim as a result of CFS, with those of future multiple s
clerosis (MS) claimants, and those of non-claimant controls (NC). Resu
lts: The study encompassed 133 CFS, 75 MS and 162 Nf cases. CFS cases
had recorded significantly more illnesses at time of proposal for insu
rance than the two control groups, and had significantly more claims b
etween proposal and diagnosis of their disorder. Almost all disease ca
tegories were reported higher in future CFS sufferers, lethargy having
the highest odds ratio after adjustment in a multivariate model. Inte
rpretation: The results of this paper on CFS patients who claim perman
ent health insurance do not support a specific viral or immunological
explanation for CFS. We conclude that abnormal illness behaviour is of
greater importance than previously recognised.