M. Serafini et al., THE CANCER REGISTRY IN THE MONITORING OF CERVICAL SCREENING PRACTICE - THE NEGLECTED VALUE OF THE PAP SMEAR IN PATIENTS DIAGNOSED WITH CIN3ON BIOPSY, European journal of cancer prevention, 7(1), 1998, pp. 45-49
Patients diagnosed with CIN3 on biopsy without a Pap smear are an inev
itable correlate of the extensive utilization of colposcopy as a basic
screening test. In a series of 248 CIN3 cases diagnosed on biopsy and
notified to the Romagna Cancer Registry between 1986 and 1993, we eva
luated the independent association between the Pap smear result and (1
) the final histology diagnosis, (2) the first choice treatment, and (
3) the appropriateness of hysterectomy. The patients were grouped into
the following categories: (1) no smear, ie colposcopy only (n = 40 or
16%), (2) CIN1, CIN2, LGSIL, and minor changes, (3) CIN3 and HGSIL, a
nd (4) carcinoma. In multiple logistic regression analysis, patients w
ithout a Pap smear were used as a reference category. Patients with sm
ears reported as CIN1-2/LGSIL or less as well as CIN3/HGSIL had a sign
ificantly lower probability of invasive squamous carcinoma (odds ratio
= 0.26 for both categories) compared with those not undergoing cytolo
gy. The Pap smear result was not a determinant of the first choice tre
atment. Hysterectomy had a greater probability of being unnecessary if
performed in patients with smears reported as showing CIN3/HGSIL (odd
s ratio = 5.05) or less. In conclusion, this registry-based study demo
nstrated that the Pap smear had an independent but neglected value in
the assessment of cases reported as CIN3 on colposcopy-guided biopsy.
(C) 1998 Rapid Science Ltd.