A. Sonnenberg et Jm. Inadomi, REVIEW ARTICLE - MEDICAL DECISION-MODELS OF HELICOBACTER-PYLORI THERAPY TO PREVENT GASTRIC-CANCER, Alimentary pharmacology & therapeutics, 12, 1998, pp. 111-121
The aim of the present article is to study the utility of Helicobacter
pylori eradication programmes in decreasing the incidence of gastric
cancer. Three types of decision models are employed to pursue this aim
, i.e. decision tree, present value, and declining exponential approxi
mation of life expectancy (DEALE). 1) A decision tree allows one to mo
del the interaction of multiple variables in great detail and to calcu
late the marginal cost, as well as the marginal cost-benefit ratio, of
a preventive strategy The cost of gastric cancer, the efficacy of H.
pylori therapy in preventing cancer, and the cumulative probability of
developing gastric cancer exert the Largest influence on the marginal
cost of cancer prevention. The high cost of future gastric cancer and
a high efficacy of therapy make screening for H. pylori and its eradi
cation the preferred strategy. 2) The present value is an economic met
hod to adjust future costs or benefits to their current value using a
discount rate and the length of time between now and a given time poin
t in the future. It accounts for the depreciation of money and all mat
erial values over time. During childhood, the present value of future
gastric cancer is very low. Vaccination of children to prevent gastric
cancer would need to be very inexpensive to be practicable. Cancer pr
evention becomes a feasible option, only if the time period between th
e preventive measures and the occurrence of gastric cancer can be made
relatively short, 3)The DEALE provides a means to calculate the incre
ase in life expectancy that would occur, if death from a particular di
sease became preventable. Life expectancy of the general population is
hardly affected by gastric cancer. For life expectancy to increase ap
preciably by vaccination or antibiotic therapy directed against H. pyl
ori infection, these interventions would need to be focused towards a
sub-population with an a priori high risk for gastric cancer.