Rdj. Froese et al., THEORETICAL-STUDY OF SUBSTITUENT EFFECTS IN THE DIIMINE-M(II) CATALYZED ETHYLENE POLYMERIZATION REACTION USING THE IMOMM METHOD, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 120(7), 1998, pp. 1581-1587
The integrated molecular orbital-molecular mechanics (IMOMM) method ad
opting the B3LYP:MM3 combination has been used to study the full catal
ysts in the diimine-M (M = Ni, Pd) catalyzed ethylene polymerization r
eaction. These results have been compared with previous molecular orbi
tal calculations on model systems (model). There is a lowering of the
migratory insertion activation barriers when including substituent eff
ects from 9.9 (model) to 3.8 (IMOMM) kcal/mol for nickel and from 16.2
(model) to 14.1 (IMOMM) kcal/mol for palladium. Steric interactions d
ecrease the complexation energy which leads to a lowering of the barri
er. The beta-H transfer process which involves the reaction n-propyl b
eta-agostic --> olefin hydride --> isopropyl beta-agostic is the likel
y mechanism leading to branching of polyethylenes. In the nickel syste
m, the olefin-hydride intermediate lies 13.6 (model) or 14.5 (IMOMM) k
cal/mol above the n-propyl beta-agostic species, indicating that this
pathway is unlikely for unsubstituted or substituted nickel diimine ca
talysts. For palladium, where the olefin-hydride intermediate resided
5.4 kcal/mol above the beta-agostic species in model B3LYP predictions
, IMOMM reduces this difference to almost zero, suggesting branching t
o be more prominent with bulky substituents. Although beta-H transfer
is more likely for substituted palladium, the formation of the 5-coord
inate intermediate is not possible due to steric effects and thus an a
ssociative chain termination process is not possible for substituted p
alladium while it likely can occur for unsubstituted Pd catalysts.