Acute hepatitis A superimposed on chronic liver disease (CLD) has been
associated with severe or fulminant hepatitis, An open, multicenter s
tudy was performed to compare the safety and immunogenicity of an inac
tivated hepatitis A vaccine in patients with CLD with that in healthy
subjects. A secondary objective was to compare the safety of the hepat
itis A vaccine with that of a commercial hepatitis B vaccine in subjec
ts with chronic hepatitis C. A total of 475 subjects over the age of 1
8 years were enrolled into 1 of 5 groups according to history, serolog
ical data, and previous diagnosis, Patients in groups 1 (healthy adult
s), 2 (chronic hepatitis B), 3 (chronic hepatitis C), and 5 (other CLD
not caused by viral hepatitis) were vaccinated with two doses of inac
tivated hepatitis A vaccine, 6 months apart, Patients in group 4 (chro
nic hepatitis C) received 3 doses of a recombinant hepatitis B vaccine
, according to a 0-, 1-, and 6-month schedule, Local injection-site sy
mptoms were the most common reactions reported following vaccination i
n all groups (35.5% of all doses), with the hepatitis B vaccine elicit
ing fewer injection-site symptoms than the hepatitis A vaccine (19.8%
compared with 37.5%), Although a higher percentage of healthy subjects
(93%) seroconverted after a single dose of the hepatitis A vaccine th
an did subjects with chronic hepatitis C (73.7%) or CLD of nonviral et
iologies (83.1%), more than 94% of all vaccinees were seropositive for
anti-HAN after the complete vaccination course. At each time point, a
lower geometric mean concentration of anti-HAV was observed for each
group of CLD patients compared with the healthy control subjects, In c
onclusion, hepatitis A vaccine was well tolerated and induced a satisf
actory immune response in patients with chronic hepatitis B, chronic h
epatitis C, and miscellaneous CLD.