M. Cosser, TOWARDS THE DESIGN OF A SYSTEM OF PEER-REVIEW OF TEACHING FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF THE INDIVIDUAL WITHIN THE UNIVERSITY, Higher education, 35(2), 1998, pp. 143-162
This study reports the results of a survey gauging academic staff resp
onse to the notion of introducing a comprehensive system of peer revie
w of teaching for summative purposes into the University of the Witwat
ersrand, Johannesburg (Wits), and, through a correlation of these resp
onses with some American perspectives on peer review, proposes a syste
m which might accommodate the needs of academic staff not only at Wits
but in any comparable institution at which student evaluation of teac
hing has come almost to preclude other forms of assessment. The paper
argues against the disjunction of formative and summative evaluation,
advocating, through the design of the peer review system proposed in t
he study, the long-term development of the individual within a concept
ion of holistic advancement in the university.