Ld. Recht et al., UNEXPECTED IN-VITRO CHEMOSENSITIVITY OF MALIGNANT GLIOMAS TO 4-HYDROXYPEROXYCYCLOPHOSPHAMIDE (4-HC), Journal of neuro-oncology, 36(3), 1998, pp. 201-208
To individually tailor chemotherapy for patients with malignant glioma
s according to tumor chemosensitivity, a rapid assay system which can
be performed with a high success rate is needed. The fluorescent cytop
rint assay (FCA) can assess multiple chemotherapeutic agents using sma
ll (approximate to 500 cells) tumor aggregates very quickly (congruent
to 1 wk). Tissue samples from 51 patients with malignant gliomas obta
ined either at time of initial diagnosis (n = 34) or at recurrence wer
e assayed using this method. The assay success rate approached 90% in
those culture samples which were histologically verified as tumor. A m
eaningful number of agents could be tested both on samples obtained by
stereotactic biopsy (median, 5) and on specimens from more extensive
resections (median, 6). One hundred ninety-three FCAs were performed o
n a samples obtained from 36 patients. In only twenty six assays (14%)
was an agent deemed sensitive (> 90% cell kill) to a chemotherapeutic
agent. Sixty-two percent of sensitive FCAs were observed in tumors te
sted against the activated analog of cyclophosphamide, 4-hydroxyperoxy
cyclophosphamide (4-HC), where a sensitivity rate (# samples sensitive
/total tested against agent) of 64 % (95 % CI, 36.6-77.9 %) was noted.
This rate was significantly higher than with any other agent tested (
p = 0.012, two sided McNemar's test) and was not affected by age, hist
ology or disease status. We conclude that: (1) the FCA represents a fe
asible method for quickly assaying tumors for sensitivity to multiple
chemotherapeutic agents; and (ii) malignant gliomas may be particularl
y sensitive to 4-HC.