P. Gaimard et al., ON THE IMPROVEMENT OF ANALYTICAL CALCULATIONS OF COLLISIONAL AURORAL ION VELOCITY DISTRIBUTIONS USING RECENT MONTE-CARLO RESULTS, J GEO R-S P, 103(A3), 1998, pp. 4079-4095
The combined effect of ion-neutral collisions and strong dc electric f
ields is known to drive marked departures from a simple Maxwellian sha
pe in the supersonic ions of the auroral ionosphere. With the current
strong interest in investigating highly disturbed periods, an accurate
knowledge of the ion distribution function is gaining in importance.
It is known that the shape of the ion velocity distribution below 500
km can have a pronounced toroidal character in the case of O+ ions whi
le looking more like an ellipsoid of revolution in the NO+ case. Calcu
lations of these effects have been made using analytical expansion tec
hniques as well as numerical Monte Carlo simulations. While the two ap
proaches yield results that are in qualitative agreement with each oth
er, we show that there can at times be some important quantitative dif
ferences between the two techniques. This should not be surprising in
view of the fact that analytic expansions are based on collision, mode
ls that are independent of the relative energy between colliding parti
cles, while the more recent Monte Carlo calculations do not suffer fro
m this limitation. This drawback notwithstanding, the advantage of ana
lytical techniques lies with the speed of the computations; these tech
niques are also free of the statistical noise that can clutter the Mon
te Carlo results. The latter can, however, be used to improve the accu
racy of the analytical calculations and therefore their usefulness. Th
is is done here by obtaining a new model of collision cross section in
tegrals which is extracted from the more recent Monte Carlo results. F
or strong dc electric field conditions, the new model can, in all case
s, greatly enhance the accuracy of the analytical temperature calculat
ions. The new model also produces overall shapes that are in better ag
reement with the numerical simulations in the NO+ case. However, even
with the new generalized cross section model, the analytical descripti
on of O+ ions remains problematic above 100 mV/m in an atmosphere with
a strong atomic oxygen content.