O. Liesvendsen et El. Olsen, COMPARISON OF KINETIC AND HYDRODYNAMIC DESCRIPTIONS OF THE PROTON POLAR WIND IN THE TRANSITION TO COLLISIONLESS FLOW, J GEO R-S P, 103(A3), 1998, pp. 4097-4113
We have compared kinetic and fluid model descriptions of the proton po
lar. wind outflow, from the collision-dominated, subsonic regime at lo
wer altitudes, through the transition to supersonic flow, and well int
o the supersonic how regime. The kinetic model is based on the Fokker-
Planck collision operator, and the two fluid models employed are based
on the 8-moment expansion and the 16-moment bi-Maxwellian expansions,
respectively. We find excellent agreement between the kinetic descrip
tion and the fluid models for the proton density and flux, even in the
transsonic and supersonic flow regimes. The models are also in qualit
ative agreement for the temperature and heat flux moments, although ne
ither fluid model reproduces the negative (downward) kinetic heat flux
es found at high altitudes. The 16-moment fluid model gives a temperat
ure anisotropy similar to the anisotropy derived from the kinetic solu
tion. The assumed forms for the velocity distribution, on which the fl
uid expansions are based, do not agree with the kinetic velocity distr
ibution, except in the subsonic region where the departure from a Maxw
ellian distribution is small. Near the fluid critical point the kineti
c model develops a double-hump distribution, with an isotropic, low-en
ergy core and an anisotropic, high-energy tail, and at higher altitude
s the distribution function develops a ''kidney bean'' shape.