SHORT-TERM PROPHYLAXIS AGAINST ESTROGEN DEPLETION-INDUCED BONE LOSS WITH CALCITRIOL DOES NOT PROVIDE LONG-TERM BENEFICIAL-EFFECTS ON CANCELLOUS BONE MASS OR STRUCTURE IN OVARIECTOMIZED RATS
Rg. Erben et al., SHORT-TERM PROPHYLAXIS AGAINST ESTROGEN DEPLETION-INDUCED BONE LOSS WITH CALCITRIOL DOES NOT PROVIDE LONG-TERM BENEFICIAL-EFFECTS ON CANCELLOUS BONE MASS OR STRUCTURE IN OVARIECTOMIZED RATS, Osteoporosis international, 8(1), 1998, pp. 82-91
It was the aim of the present study to investigate whether a 2-month p
rophylaxis of postovariectomy bone loss with low-dose calcitriol would
have long-lasting beneficial effects on cancellous bone mass or struc
ture after its withdrawal in rats, Six-month-old female Fischer 344 ra
ts were either ovariectomized (OVX) or sham-operated (SHAM). Groups of
SHAM and OVX rats were orally treated with either 0.05 mu g calcitrio
l/kg per day or vehicle for 2 months postovariectomy starting immediat
ely after ovariectomy. Thereafter, the rats were maintained without tr
eatment for another 4 months. Half the animals in each group were kill
ed 2 months postovariectomy; the rest of the rats were killed 6 months
postovariectomy. Cancellous bone histomorphometry was performed on th
e first lumbar vertebral body and on the proximal tibial metaphysis. A
dminstration of low-dose calcitriol to SHAM and OVX rats resulted in h
yper calciuria, but not hypercalcemia. By 2 months postovariectomy, ca
lcitriol treatment of OVX rats had completely prevented tibial trabecu
lar bone loss, and had increased vertebral cancellous bone mass in SHA
M and OVX rats by about 30% over the level observed in SHAM vehicle co
ntrols. However, at the end of the experiment, i.e. 4 months after wit
hdrawal of calcitriol, cancellous bone mass and structure in both the
vertebrae and the tibiae of calcitriol-treated OVX rats were almost id
entical to those of vehicle-treated OVX rats. We conclude that prevent
ion of bone loss with low-dose calcitriol during the phase of acute es
trogen deficiency, when bone turnover is maximally increased, does not
provide long-term beneficial effects on cancellous bone mass or struc
ture in OVX rats. If extrapolated to postmenopausal women, this study
would suggest that prophylaxis against postmenopausal bone loss with s
hort-acting antiresorptive substances during only the first few years
after menopause will probably not reduce the risk of postmenopausal os
teoporosis later in life.