N. Tubridy et al., SECONDARY PROGRESSIVE MULTIPLE-SCLEROSIS - THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SHORT-TERM MRI ACTIVITY AND CLINICAL-FEATURES, Brain, 121, 1998, pp. 225-231
We report the findings in 60 patients with secondary progressive multi
ple sclerosis who had monthly brain MRI studies for 4 months (one base
line and three follow-up scans). The purpose was to define the short-t
erm MRI natural history in a large cohort with secondary progressive d
isease and to ascertain its relationship with other clinical and MRI f
eatures. The patients were participating in either a natural history s
tudy or the placebo arm or non-treatment phase of a therapeutic trial.
The cohort had clinical features typical of secondary progressive dis
ease: thus, all had moderate or severe locomotor disabilities [Expande
d Disability Status Scale (EDSS), score 3.5-8], with a median disease
duration of 12 years. There was equal representation of males and fema
les. During the 3 months of follow-up there was a total of 362 new enh
ancing lesions seen in 42 patients, and there were 24 relapses in 20 p
atients. There was no correlation between new enhancing lesions and ag
e at study entry age of disease onset, gender disease duration or EDSS
, but there was a strong correlation with the number of enhancing lesi
ons on the baseline scan (r = 0.65, P < 0.0001) and subsequent activit
y There was a non-significant trend for higher numbers of new, enhanci
ng lesions in those having relapses during the 3 months of scanning (P
= 0.14) or in the preceding 6 months (P = 0.06). The 34 patients who
did not relapse in either period had significantly fewer new active le
sions (P = 0.02) than those who relapsed at some stage during the 9 mo
nths. Nevertheless, considerable activity was seen in rite non-relapsi
ng cohorts: there was a mean of 3.5 (median 2) new enhancing lesions i
n those not relapsing during the 3 month study, and 5.5 (median 2) in
those not relapsing in the previous 6 months. We conclude that short-t
erm MRI activity is generally high in secondary progressive disease, c
onfirming a useful role for the technique in exploratory trials. Furth
er work should concentrate on elucidating the mechanisms of secondary
progression by longer term follow-up studies of larger cohorts rising
multiple MRI and clinical measurements.