M. Hegedus et al., ASSESSMENT OF NUTRITIONAL ADEQUACY OF THE PROTEIN IN DOG FOODS BY TRIALS ON GROWING RATS, Acta veterinaria Hungarica, 46(1), 1998, pp. 61-70
In order to offer methods for assessing the protein quality of dog foo
ds, eight commercial dry-type complete dog foods were analysed by in v
itro chemical methods (crude protein, amino acid composition, in vitro
pepsin digestibility) and rat growth trial (weight gain = WG, feed ef
ficiency = FE, protein efficiency ratio = PER, net protein ratio = NPR
, and net protein utilisation = NPU). Three individual samples were ta
ken from each dog food and their homogenous mixture was used as an ing
redient for the test diets fed to six rats per diet. All dog food samp
les were used as a single protein source in isonitrogenous (10% crude
protein) and isoenergetic (ME = 14.9 MJ/kg) complete diets. Rat weight
gains showed significant differences among most of the test diets as
a consequence of the differences in protein quality of the dog food sa
mples. The protein quality indices of the dog food products showed sig
nificant variations. The measured ranges of protein quality indices of
the samples were as follows: WG = -5.4-21.4 g; FE = 0-0.25 g/g; PER =
0-2.54 g/g; NPR = 1.06-3.52 g/g; NPU = 19.93-65.93%. The limiting ami
no acid, the sum of essential amino acids and the chemical scores were
calculated from gross amino acid composition. Tryptophan was the firs
t limiting amino acids in all samples but one. Methionine was found to
be the second limiting amino acid. The crude protein content of the s
amples showed no correlation with indices of protein quality, indicati
ng that the declaration of crude protein is not a sufficient informati
on to judge the protein quality of dog foods. The declaration of NPR,
or NPU indices may be recommended for labelling the protein quality of
premium-type dog foods.