Rc. Schimmer et al., ARTHOSCOPIC PARTIAL MENISCECTOMY - A 12-YEAR FOLLOW-UP AND 2-STEP EVALUATION OF THE LONG-TERM COURSE, Arthroscopy, 14(2), 1998, pp. 136-142
The long-term results after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy of 119 p
atients with a mean follow-up of 12 years are presented in this study.
The same series of patients had an earlier follow-up 4 years postoper
atively. Thus, an evaluation of the actual long-term course and not on
ly a single result after partial meniscectomy is presented. Arthroscop
ic partial meniscectomy is shown to be the definitive means of therapy
for meniscal lesion of the knee joint; 91.7% of patients had an excel
lent or good result 4 years after surgery, and 78.1% rated excellent o
r good 12. years after surgery. Full recovery regarding ability to wor
k and sports activity level was achieved in a very high percentage of
patients. Early results were mostly representative and did not change
significantly during the long-term course for the isolated meniscal le
sion. The factor with the highest impact on long-term results was dama
ge to the articular cartilage, which did not influence knee function f
or several years after surgery but became increasingly symptomatic ove
r time after 5 years and more. Only 62% of patients with additional ca
rtilage damage rated excellent and good 12 years after surgery, in con
trast with 94.8% good and excellent results in patients with isolated
meniscal tears. Similar observations were made for the untreated ruptu
re of the anterior cruciate ligament.